Ephesians 4Church GovernmentThe Fivefold Ministry

The Measure & the Fullness

Why the ascended Christ gave apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors and teachers to His church, and why no one of us was ever meant to carry the whole.

Most arguments about church government begin with power. Who is in charge? Who answers to whom? Who gets the last word when the leaders disagree? Bishops, boards, ballots: for seventeen centuries the debate has run along that single track, and it has produced every possible arrangement of the same question.

Paul begins somewhere else. When he finally sets out, in Ephesians 4, to explain how the risen Christ governs His church, he does not open with authority. He opens with a shortage.

“But to each one of us grace was given according to the measure of Christ’s gift.”

Ephesians 4:7

Each one of us has a measure, and no one has the whole. Read Ephesians 4 with that in view and the fivefold ministry stops looking like an organizational chart somebody laid over the church. It is God’s provision for people who were never given enough to reach His purpose on their own.

That is the argument of this article. Church government, rightly understood, begins as the answer to a far humbler question than “Who rules?” It answers this one: How do people who each hold a partial portion of grace come to share the whole? Settle that, and most of the old quarrels about authority sort themselves out.

—

The third stone

There is a reason this question deserves more than a debate about polity. The writer of Hebrews lists the foundation of the church, the first things every believer was expected to have settled before pressing on:

“Therefore leaving the elementary teaching about the Christ, let us press on to maturity, not laying again a foundation of repentance from dead works and of faith toward God, of instruction about washings and laying on of hands, and the resurrection of the dead and eternal judgment.”

Hebrews 6:1–2

Four stones on the rock

THE HOUSE “growing into a holy temple” Eph 2:21 GROUND PLUMB LINE Christ the cornerstone the measure for every stone Eph 2:20 STONE I Repentance & faith Heb 6:1 STONE II Baptisms of water & Spirit Heb 6:2 STONE III Laying on of hands Heb 6:2 · THIS ARTICLE STONE IV Resurrection & judgment Heb 6:2 THE BEDROCK · MATTHEW 16:16–18 Who is Jesus? “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.”
Figure 1Hebrews 6:1–2 names the foundation in four stones. They rest on the bedrock of who Jesus is, and every one of them is squared to Christ, the cornerstone. This article is about the third.

That sentence names four stones: repentance and faith, the baptisms of water and Spirit, the laying on of hands, and the resurrection and the judgment. All four rest on bedrock, the revelation Peter received of who Jesus is (Matt. 16:16–18), and all four are squared to Christ, the cornerstone. Most believers can say something about the first, the second and the fourth. Ask about the third and you will usually hear about a prayer line. Yet the writer does not file it with the deep things. He calls it elementary, among the first things a believer should be taught (Heb. 5:12).

To a Hebrew reader the phrase needed no explanation. For centuries before Pentecost, this was how a father passed on what he carried. When a patriarch was ready to hand on the birthright, he laid his right hand on the head of his heir and blessed him. The family name, the inheritance, the place at the head of the tribe and the duty that came with it: all of it passed from father to son through the hand.

Joseph brought his two boys to his dying father and stood them so that Manasseh, the firstborn, would come under Jacob’s right hand. The old man, his eyes too dim to see, crossed his arms. “Israel stretched out his right hand and laid it on the head of Ephraim, who was the younger, and his left hand on Manasseh’s head, crossing his hands, although Manasseh was the firstborn” (Gen. 48:14). Joseph thought his father had made a mistake and took hold of his hand to move it. Jacob refused: “I know, my son, I know” (Gen. 48:19). Joseph would not have argued over an empty gesture. He knew the birthright went with that right hand, and so did Jacob. In The Right Hand of Power and the Name of Yahweh, my father, Blair Adams, called it “passing on the relational authority to preserve the vision of a culture of life,” an act “not merely conventional but prophetic.”

The crossed hands

ISRAEL “I know, my son, I know” Gen 48:19 JOSEPH “Not so, my father” Gen 48:18 Gen 48:14 the firstborn · the left hand the younger · the right hand
Figure 2Joseph set the firstborn under his father’s right hand. Jacob crossed his arms and laid the hand of the birthright on the younger. Joseph tried to move it, and Jacob would not let him. The blessing went where the hand was laid.

The church never stopped doing it. When the elders ordain a man to the ministry, they lay their hands on him and set him in his place as authorized by God (Acts 13:3; 1 Tim. 4:14). When a man and woman kneel to be married, the minister lays his hands on their heads and institutes the marriage as of God. When we pray over the sick, the Lord stretches out His hand through ours: “they will lay hands on the sick, and they will recover” (Mark 16:18). Even the welcome into the church is a hand: “the right hand of fellowship” (Gal. 2:9).

What do these have in common? Of all the ways God might have conferred authority, He chose the most personal one: a father’s hand on a son’s head. The laying on of hands is the doctrine of how authority is set in place in the kingdom. It is the baton passed from hand to hand, the concrete transfer of dominion within the church, to the church, and through the church into the world.

Ephesians 4 is the laying on of hands written out in full: how the ascended Christ placed His own ministry in men, how those men are recognized and set in their place, and how what was given to one reaches another. Leave this stone out and the house still goes up. Ballots will build it, or charisma, or whoever speaks loudest. But it will not be built by the hand of God. If we do not understand how His anointed authority is expressed in and through the church, we are missing a foundation stone, and nothing we build on the upper floors will make up for it.

I

The only Man who had it all

John writes of Jesus, “He whom God has sent speaks the words of God; for He gives the Spirit without measure” (John 3:34). In Him, Paul writes, “all the fullness of Deity dwells in bodily form” (Col. 2:9). Follow Jesus through the Gospels and you find every ministry the church would ever need, carried in one body:

  • ApostleThe One sent from the Father. “Consider Jesus, the Apostle and High Priest of our confession” (Heb. 3:1).
  • ProphetThe Prophet Moses promised: “The Lord God will raise up for you a prophet like me” (Acts 3:22).
  • EvangelistAnointed “to preach the gospel to the poor” (Luke 4:18).
  • Shepherd“I am the good shepherd; the good shepherd lays down His life for the sheep” (John 10:11).
  • Teacher“You call Me Teacher and Lord; and you are right, for so I am” (John 13:13).

Then He ascended, and when the one Man who carried it all left the earth, He did not hand His ministry to a single successor. He broke it apart and gave it away.

“When He ascended on high, He led captive a host of captives, and He gave gifts to men.… And He gave some as apostles, and some as prophets, and some as evangelists, and some as pastors and teachers.”

Ephesians 4:8, 11

The fullness that walked the roads of Galilee in one body was distributed, on purpose, across many. No pope inherited it, no celebrity evangelist, no senior pastor. The ascended Christ divided His own ministry into five gifts and placed them in different men, so that none of them could ever again be the whole.

If you want to find the ministry of Jesus on the earth today, you will not find it in a man. You will find it in a body.

One fullness, given in five parts

Christ the Spirit without measure JOHN 3:34 APOSTLE Heb 3:1 PROPHET Acts 3:22 EVANGELIST Luke 4:18 PASTOR John 10:11 TEACHER John 13:13 “WHEN HE ASCENDED … HE GAVE GIFTS TO MEN” · EPH 4:8, 11
Figure 3Every gift Christ gives the church is a portion of a ministry He first carried whole. The gifts are not added to Him; they are distributed from Him.
II

Measured on purpose

Go back to verse 7 and notice where Paul puts it. He has just stacked up seven “ones”: “one body and one Spirit … one hope … one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all who is over all and through all and in all” (Eph. 4:4–6). God is whole, undivided, complete in Himself. Then comes one small word that turns the whole passage: “But to each one of us grace was given according to the measure of Christ’s gift.”

μέτρον metron · Eph 4:7, 13, 16 A measure: the word for a measuring vessel, a measuring rod, a fixed allotment. You received the Spirit. You did not receive all of Him.

Paul calls what we hold “the first fruits of the Spirit” (Rom. 8:23) and “a pledge” (2 Cor. 1:22). Anyone who has worked a garden knows what the first picking looks like. It is the earliest, the most longed-for, and the smallest part of the harvest. It proves the crop is real. It will not carry the family through the winter.

That is the honest condition of every born-again believer. Your measure was enough to bring you to birth. It is not enough to bring you to maturity, not by yourself. You will not see everything God is saying. You will not carry every grace your own life requires. If our deposit of the Spirit were larger, we would see more clearly, trust more readily, and come to agreement far sooner than we do. The chief obstacle to the unity of the church is not bad personalities or even bad doctrine. Underneath both lies the smallness of each person’s portion.

Why would God arrange it this way? He could have filled every believer to the brim. Scripture gives at least two reasons He did not.

The first is humility. One creature has already tried to hold more than his measure. Lucifer would not keep his assigned place, and he fell for it, along with “the angels who did not keep their own domain” (Jude 6). A believer with the Spirit without measure would be a believer with need of no one, and a man who needs no one is one short step from making himself a god. Paul draws the line himself: “not to think more highly of himself than he ought to think; but to think so as to have sound judgment, as God has allotted to each a measure of faith” (Rom. 12:3). The measure is a mercy. It keeps us small enough to be saved.

The second is love. God made us partial so that we would need one another. “To each one is given the manifestation of the Spirit for the common good” (1 Cor. 12:7). Your portion was given to you. It was never given for you alone. Some of what you need was deposited in your brother, and some of what he needs was deposited in you. God left gaps in each of us on purpose, so another member would have a place to fit.

The pattern is old. When Moses buckled under the weight of a complaining nation, God did not give him more strength. He gave him more men, and He did it by dividing the Spirit that was on one man among many: “I will take of the Spirit who is upon you, and will put Him upon them; and they shall bear the burden of the people with you, so that you will not bear it all alone” (Num. 11:17). Seventy elders received a portion of what rested on Moses, and the load that was crushing one became bearable for many.

The same wilderness shows how such a portion passes on. When Moses’ days were ending, God told him, “Take Joshua the son of Nun, a man in whom is the Spirit, and lay your hand on him … You shall put some of your authority on him” (Num. 27:18, 20). Scripture records the result at Moses’ grave: “Now Joshua the son of Nun was filled with the spirit of wisdom, for Moses had laid his hands on him” (Deut. 34:9). Joshua received his measure through Moses’ hand.

Paul reached for another wilderness picture when he urged the churches to share with one another. Israel’s manna was never gathered in equal amounts, but it was eaten in shared ones: “He who gathered much did not have too much, and he who gathered little had no lack” (2 Cor. 8:15). The abundance in one tent covered the lack in another.

Partaking of one another’s portions

EACH ALONEmuch here, little thereJOINEDthe abundance of one supplies the lack of anotherEVERY JOINT OF SUPPLY · EPH 4:16“He who gathered much did not have too much, and he who gathered little had no lack.” 2 Cor 8:15
Figure 4Joined vessels find one level. The joints in Christ’s body let what was deposited in one member reach the need of another.
The question is not whether you have enough. You don’t. Neither do I. The question is whether there is a way for your portion and mine to reach each other.

That is exactly the question Ephesians 4 goes on to answer.

III

Three measures in one chapter

Paul’s argument in Ephesians 4 turns on four small connecting words. Read them in order and you have the whole doctrine in outline.

The logic of Ephesians 4, in four hinges

  1. Butv. 7Each of us received only a measure of Christ’s gift.
  2. Thereforevv. 8, 11–12The ascended Christ gave apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors and teachers to equip the saints.
  3. Untilv. 13We all attain to one mature man, the measure of the stature of Christ’s fullness.
  4. As a resultv. 14We are no longer children, tossed by waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine.
Figure 5Without verse 7 there would be no need for verse 11. The fivefold ministry exists because no one has enough.

Now follow the word measure. It appears three times in the passage, and the three uses tell the whole story.

Verse 7 gives the first: “to each one of us … the measure of Christ’s gift.” A small measure, distributed person by person.

Verse 13 gives the second: “until we all attain … to a mature man, to the measure of the stature which belongs to the fullness of Christ.” This is a measure no individual can hold. Notice who reaches it. Paul does not say “until each of you attains.” He says “until we all attain … to a mature man,” singular: one new man formed out of many partial ones. I have heard sincere believers speak of their private devotional life as a pursuit of “the full stature of Christ.” Paul never promises that to any individual. It is not humility to aim for it alone. It is impossible, and it makes the church unnecessary.

Verse 16 gives the third, though most English translations smooth it over. The NASB says the body grows “according to the proper working of each individual part.” Paul’s Greek is more vivid: the body grows kat’ energeian en metrō henos hekastou merous, “according to the working, in measure, of each one part.”

So the chapter opens with each one’s small measure. It closes with each one’s measure working in its place. And between them it names a third measure, the stature of Christ’s fullness, that no single member will ever hold but all of us together can reach. The fivefold ministry stands in the middle of the passage as the bridge from the first measure to the third.

No single rod reaches the stature. Joined, they do.

THE MEASURE OF THE STATURE OF THE FULLNESS OF CHRIST · v. 13 TO EACH ONE A MEASURE · v. 7 JOINED AT EVERY JOINT OF SUPPLY · v. 16 by the equipping gifts vv. 11–12 every jointof supply ONE MATURE MAN · v. 13
Figure 6The word for “stature” (hēlikia) means height or full growth. Each member’s measure is real but short. The equipping gifts set the members into joint so the measures add up, until the body stands at the height of Christ.

What joins the measures together? Verse 16 answers: the whole body is “fitted and held together by what every joint supplies.”

ἐπιχορηγία epichorēgia · Eph 4:16 Supply. The word grew out of the chorēgos of ancient Athens, the patron who bore the whole cost of equipping a chorus. In the body, the joints are where supply passes from one member to the next.

And verse 12 tells us whose labor makes the joints: the five gifts were given “for the equipping of the saints for the work of service, to the building up of the body of Christ.”

καταρτισμός katartismos · Eph 4:12 Equipping, setting in order. Its verb is used of fishermen mending their torn nets (Matt. 4:21), and by ancient physicians of setting a broken or dislocated bone.

The fivefold ministry does not do the work of the body for it. A doctor setting a dislocated shoulder does not do the arm’s work; he puts the arm back where it can do its own. The equipping gifts set the members back into joint so the supply can flow.

Each of us holds a measure. The fivefold ministry is the order God built so that we can partake of one another’s measures, so that what was deposited in you reaches me and what was deposited in me reaches you, until together we have enough to attain a high calling none of us could reach alone. Apostolic order is the pipe. Grace is the water. Make it all about the pipe and you have missed the point. Try to do without a pipe and the water soaks into the ground.

IV

Five gifts, one hand

Partial vessels do not pour themselves into one another by instinct. Put a hundred believers in a room, each holding a real measure of the Spirit, and you do not automatically get a body. Very often you get the opposite: each measure begins to mistake itself for the whole.

A man with an evangelist’s portion looks at every problem in the church and sees one solution. We don’t need all this. Just get people saved. Pray them through and we’re set. His brother, who carries a teacher’s portion, grows frustrated, leaves, and plants a church across the street on the conviction that the answer to everything is better teaching. Each man was right about what the others lacked. Neither could see what he lacked himself. And so each builds a tabernacle around his own eccentricity and calls it God’s gift to the church. Left there, measure without order breeds sects.

So the measures need an order, an arrangement that tells each portion where it fits and how it connects to the rest. Scripture insists that such an order exists. “God has placed the members, each one of them, in the body, just as He desired” (1 Cor. 12:18). “God has appointed in the church, first apostles, second prophets, third teachers” (1 Cor. 12:28). God placed them, God appointed them, and Paul numbers them. That is the language of a design, not of a spontaneous gathering.

The Bible has a picture for this design that runs from the Exodus to the book of Acts: the right hand of God. “Your right hand, O Lord, is majestic in power” (Ex. 15:6). God brought Israel out of Egypt “by a mighty hand and by an outstretched arm” (Deut. 5:15). The first church prayed that God would “extend Your hand to heal” through His servants (Acts 4:30), and when the pillars of Jerusalem recognized Paul’s calling, they gave him “the right hand of fellowship” (Gal. 2:9). My father, Blair Adams, saw the five ascension gifts as the five fingers of that hand.

The right hand of God’s power

PROPHETpoints where God is lookingEVANGELISTreaches farthest beyond the bodyPASTORconforms lives to the truthTEACHERmakes the pattern plainring and little fingerrarely move apartAPOSTLEtouches every finger;makes the grip possible“YOUR RIGHT HAND, O LORD, IS MAJESTIC IN POWER” · EX 15:6
Mobile ministries: travel among congregations Local ministries: present in every congregation
Figure 7Lose a finger and the hand is weaker. Lose the thumb and it cannot grip anything at all. The picture is about function: each finger can do what the others cannot.

Here is what each finger carries, and what a church loses without it.

Apostleἀπόστολος · one sent

The thumb

A master builder who lays foundations and gives the pattern for the house (1 Cor. 3:10; Eph. 2:20). He founds churches, orders their life, and coordinates the other gifts. Only the thumb can touch each of the four fingers; only the apostolic gift ministers to all the others.

Without it: every gift builds by its own blueprint, and the house never rises.

Prophetπροφήτης · one who speaks forth

The index finger

Keeps the vision and points where God is looking. Prophets confirm the apostolic work and call the church back when it drifts, the way Haggai and Zechariah stood beside Zerubbabel and Joshua while the temple was rebuilt (Ezra 5:1–2).

Without it: a church keeps busy and loses its direction.

Evangelistεὐαγγελιστής · bearer of good news

The middle finger

Reaches farthest beyond the body. The evangelist is the midwife of new birth, bringing seekers through repentance, baptism, and the gift of the Holy Spirit, and he reaches the unconverted children inside the church as well as the stranger outside it.

Without it: the body stops being born. Cut loose from the hand, it leaves orphans.

Pastorποιμήν · shepherd

The ring finger

A conforming ministry. The pastor fathers individual lives into the truth, binding up the hurt and keeping watch “as those who will give an account” (Heb. 13:17), without smothering the flock or doing its repenting for it.

Without it: people hear the truth and never become it.

Teacherδιδάσκαλος · instructor

The little finger

An informing ministry. The teacher brings no new revelation; he takes what was given through the foundational ministries and breaks the bread small enough for everyone to eat, without losing its weight or anointing (2 Tim. 2:2).

Without it: the pattern stays in the architect’s head.

Apostles, prophets, and evangelists tend to travel among congregations, and that mobility is what binds many local churches into one body rather than a loose federation of independent ones. Pastors and teachers need to be permanently present in every congregation, working alongside the local elders and the deacons who carry the practical life of the church (Acts 6:1–6; 1 Tim. 3:1–13).

Each of these is a portion of the ministry Jesus once carried whole. A church built around one of them is a church trying to pick something up with one finger.

Set the five-fingered hand beside the laying on of hands in Hebrews 6. The fivefold ministry is how the ascended Christ keeps laying His hand on His church: setting men in their places and passing on what He once carried whole.

Is there an order among the five? Scripture gives one, though not a ladder. Apostles and prophets are the foundational ministries; the church is “built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets” (Eph. 2:20), and among those two, apostolic wisdom presides. Evangelists, pastors, and teachers are not ranked against one another. They are partners, each answerable within his own gift to proven elders of that gift and, together, to the pattern the foundational ministries have laid. Notice that when Paul lists “first apostles, second prophets, third teachers” (1 Cor. 12:28), evangelists and pastors are missing. Teachers are named because, like apostles and prophets, they minister to the church as a whole. Evangelists and pastors reach chiefly to individuals, the one bringing them into the body and the other bringing them to maturity within it.

And how do the five gifts relate to the elders and deacons of the Pastoral Epistles? Ephesians 4 never mentions elders, and 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1 never mention the five gifts, because they are describing two different things. The five gifts name the kind of ministry a man carries. “Elder” (presbyter, overseer) names the level of maturity and responsibility at which he carries it. A man of any of the five gifts grows from associate, to commissioned, to ordained elder, and many serve faithfully for life at the first or second level without any loss. Most elders carry one of the five gifts, though some serve chiefly by ruling well (1 Tim. 5:17); what makes a man an elder is his calling, his maturity, and his proven character. The elders together govern. The deacons, overseen by a presiding elder, carry the practical life of the church: its finances, its building, its care for the needy (Acts 6:1–6; 1 Tim. 3:8–13).

A gift is a kind; eldership is a level

APOSTLEPROPHETEVANGELISTPASTORTEACHERTHE ELDERS TOGETHER GOVERNORDAINED ELDERpresbyter · overseerCOMMISSIONEDASSOCIATEgrowthDEACONSpractical service: finances, building, care for the needy · overseen by a presiding elder
Figure 8Most elders carry one of the five gifts. Many faithful ministers serve for life at the associate or commissioned level, “according to the grace given to us” (Rom. 12:6).

What marks an apostle

When the Corinthians questioned whether Paul was an apostle at all, he answered them in 2 Corinthians 10–12. The marks below follow the order of his answer.

First, it builds, within the sphere God assigned (2 Cor. 10:13–16). Paul calls himself “a wise master builder” (1 Cor. 3:10). The Greek word is architektōn, an architect. A superintendent runs the job site and a project manager keeps the crews on schedule, and either may be better at that than the architect. But the architect sees the whole building. The apostolic gift brings together ministries that would otherwise compete. And what he builds stands: “you are the seal of my apostleship in the Lord” (1 Cor. 9:2).

Second, his gospel is the apostles’ gospel. The false apostles at Corinth preached “another Jesus” and “a different gospel” (2 Cor. 11:4, 13). Paul laid the gospel he preached before James, Cephas, and John, men he did not raise and who owed him nothing. When they recognized “the grace that had been given to me,” they gave him the right hand of fellowship (Gal. 2:2, 9). The church is still told to test “those who call themselves apostles” (Rev. 2:2), and the gospel the apostles delivered is the standard it tests them by.

Third, he seeks nothing for himself. Paul preached to Corinth without charge and “kept myself from being a burden to you” (2 Cor. 11:7–9). False apostles do the opposite. They enslave, devour, take advantage, and exalt themselves (11:20).

Fourth, he endures. Paul’s longest list of credentials is a list of sufferings: labors, beatings, prisons, shipwrecks, hunger, cold (2 Cor. 11:23–27). An apostle is known by what he endures (1 Cor. 4:9–13).

Fifth, he carries every part of the church. Paul’s list of sufferings ends with “the daily pressure on me of concern for all the churches. Who is weak without my being weak?” (2 Cor. 11:28–29). “I have become all things to all men” (1 Cor. 9:22). He can stand in all four gifts. He will always be stronger in his primary gift, but he has served in all of them, so the evangelist, the pastor, the prophet, and the teacher each know he understands them. Give the apostolic role to a man who lacks this, and he will bend the church into the shape of his own gift: one gift becomes what ministry looks like, instead of all four. Most of our quarrels come from exactly this. Ministers judge the body through the lens of their own gift and call a difference in gifting a failure of character.

A simple test: when ministers who disagree need someone to settle it, whom do they ask for? If they choose a man because they trust him to give all four gifts their weight, the gift may be there. If one side wants him because they are sure he will take their part, it is not.

Sixth, he carries revelation in weakness. Paul turns next to “visions and revelations of the Lord” (2 Cor. 12:1), and then to the thorn that kept him from exalting himself: “power is perfected in weakness” (12:9). The gift is what he calls “insight into the mystery of Christ” (Eph. 3:4), seeing more of how God means the building to fit together than others can see. None of it depends on personality. His critics said “his personal presence is unimpressive and his speech contemptible” (2 Cor. 10:10), and my father taught that an apostle may be a quiet man who rarely preaches. Leadership skill helps, but it is not the gift.

Seventh, God attests it. Only now does Paul name the signs: “The signs of a true apostle were performed among you with all perseverance, by signs and wonders and miracles” (2 Cor. 12:12). Perseverance comes first. The miracles come not every day, and not on demand, but a gift this weighty demands evidence of God’s supernatural confirmation.

Eighth, he loves as a father. Paul closes his defense this way: “I do not seek what is yours, but you; for children are not responsible to save up for their parents, but parents for their children. I will most gladly spend and be expended for your souls” (2 Cor. 12:14–15).

V

Four substitutes for a body

When the church lost sight of the measure, it began to treat its government as a problem of power: who should hold it, and how to keep it in check. Over the centuries four answers have dominated. Each has something true in it. Each, I believe, misses what Ephesians 4 is about.

Rule by position. As the church settled into the Roman Empire, its government came to mirror the empire’s. Even the word diocese was first the name of a Roman administrative district. Bishops presided over territories the way governors presided over provinces, and authority came from where a man sat in the hierarchy rather than from the gift God had placed in him. The arrangement preserved uniformity across great distances. It did so by making the Spirit’s direct guidance optional.

Rule by council. The Reformation recovered the plurality of elders, and the Presbyterian answer built it into a ladder of elected bodies: session, presbytery, synod, general assembly. Representation and accountability are real virtues. But the system tries to restrain natural-minded authority with natural-minded procedure, and the Spirit tends to move faster than the committee.

Rule by majority. In the congregational model every church is autonomous and every office is filled by vote. Yet the New Testament never once shows a congregation electing an apostle, a prophet, or an elder. The congregation in Acts 6 selected men to serve tables; the apostles appointed them and laid hands on them. Elders were appointed (Acts 14:23; Titus 1:5). A congregation electing its spiritual fathers is like children electing their parents. Nor did Paul treat churches as autonomous: “so I direct in all the churches” (1 Cor. 7:17). The Jerusalem council of Acts 15 settled a question for churches that never sent a delegate.

Rule by one gifted man. This is the model most evangelicals actually live under, whatever their denomination says on paper. One man preaches, counsels, administrates, evangelizes, raises funds, casts vision, and referees every quarrel. Jethro warned Moses what happens next: “You will surely wear out, both yourself and these people who are with you, for the task is too heavy for you; you cannot do it alone” (Ex. 18:18).

Four ways to arrange power, one way to arrange portions

Episcopal

Rule by position

Authority flows from the office held.

Presbyterian

Rule by council

Authority flows from elected bodies.

Congregational

Rule by majority

Authority flows up from the vote.

Pastor-CEO

Rule by one man

Every need runs through a single gift.

The fivefold body

Ordered by gift, joined as family

Authority flows from the Head, through gifts He placed, in relationships of trust.

Figure 9The first four models answer the question “Who holds power?” The fifth answers a different question: “How does the portion in each member reach every other member?”

All four answer the question of power. None of them answers the question of measure. Not one asks what portion of Christ’s ministry a man actually carries, or arranges the portions so they can reach each other. A bishop’s chair, an elected board, and a majority vote can all be filled by men who carry the wrong gift, or by one gift trying to do the work of five. And the pastor-CEO model simply asks one partial vessel to act as though he were full. We should not be surprised when he cracks.

What does Scripture offer instead? Paul tells us in the verses that lead directly into Ephesians 4: “For this reason I bow my knees before the Father, from whom every family in heaven and on earth derives its name” (Eph. 3:14–15). The government of the church is a fatherhood. Paul did not write to Corinth, “I hold office over you.” He wrote, “you would not have many fathers, for in Christ Jesus I became your father through the gospel” (1 Cor. 4:15).

Fathers are not elected, and they cannot appoint themselves. They are recognized. A gift is first seen operating in the body; it bears fruit over time; and those already proven in that ministry confirm what God has evidently done, as the prophets and teachers at Antioch laid hands on Barnabas and Saul and sent them out (Acts 13:1–3), and as Timothy received his gift “through prophetic utterance with the laying on of hands by the presbytery” (1 Tim. 4:14). “And no one takes the honor to himself, but receives it when he is called by God, even as Aaron was” (Heb. 5:4). How that recognition is guarded among us, and how a man can be removed, I describe below.

And this authority is noncoercive. It carries no sword, no lawsuit, no threat. It has sway only over those who freely recognize it. Every believer who chooses to follow a ministry is, in effect, casting a vote of confidence in it every day, and can withdraw that confidence. That is a more searching accountability than any annual ballot.

VI

How authority works in a body

An organizational chart has one kind of authority: positional. Whoever sits in the box above you directs whoever sits in the box below, regardless of gifting, maturity, or what the Spirit is doing that afternoon. A living body works differently. In your own hand, bone, nerve, and tendon all carry authority at the same moment, each of a different kind. The body of Christ is the same. Three strands of authority run through it at once.

Three strands, one body

The nerve

The Spirit speaking through any member

God reserves the right to speak through whomever He chooses. When Nathan said, “You are the man!” (2 Sam. 12:7), King David, himself a prophet, bowed. “You can all prophesy one by one” (1 Cor. 14:31). This authority is real but momentary. It belongs to the word, and it is gone the moment a man tries to turn it into a permanent position.

The tendon

Fathers and sons

This authority governs a man’s character, not his gift, and it does not track rank. A pastor may father the life of a man whose prophetic gift outstrips his own. Every minister among us, up to the most senior, keeps his life open to someone with real access to his marriage, his money, and his temper. However large a man’s gift, it cannot pastor his own character.

The bone

Placement in an ordered gift

“First apostles, second prophets, third teachers” (1 Cor. 12:28). The gifts have a real sequence in the work of building, and within each gift a man grows from associate to commissioned to ordained ministry. He enters that order only as a son: his gift seen, his fruit tested, his calling confirmed by fathers already proven in it.

Figure 10Take away the Head’s living presence and this model has nothing left to run on. That is intentional: a structure that can run without the Spirit sooner or later will.

That confirmation is what the laying on of hands means. The elders do not create the gift; they recognize it, and lay their hands on what God has already placed. Elijah could throw his mantle over Elisha, but the double portion was not his to give. It was his to confirm.

Think of a surgical team. The attending surgeon has real authority over the operation; no one questions who is directing the work. But when the anesthesiologist says “Stop,” the whole room stops, including the surgeon. And the surgeon’s own health is in the hands of some other doctor. Authority by placement, authority by the moment, authority over the person: three kinds at once, and no one confuses them. Nobody in that room thinks the arrangement is tyranny. They think it is how you keep a patient alive.

Take the most senior gift. An apostle may preside, but he is the most hemmed-in man in the body. He submits his personal life to someone serving as a pastor to him. He honors his father and older men regardless of their gifting. He can be corrected “on the basis of two or three witnesses” (1 Tim. 5:19). He answers to fellow apostles and to the ordained eldership, who can remove him if his character or doctrine breaks down. And he stands before the whole congregation, which Christ Himself commends for testing “those who call themselves apostles, and they are not” (Rev. 2:2).

Far from sitting atop a pyramid, he is held in place from every side, so that the gift God put in him can serve everyone else.

Why would anyone choose to live inside so many limits? Because that is the only way glory has ever come to a human being. Look at the one Man who carried the Spirit without measure. He said, “the Son can do nothing of Himself, unless it is something He sees the Father doing” (John 5:19), and “the words that I say to you I do not speak on My own initiative, but the Father abiding in Me does His works” (John 14:10). The Son submitted, and the Father worked through Him. Paul draws the line from there to us: “He humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross. For this reason also, God highly exalted Him” (Phil. 2:8–9). Then he adds a sentence that is easy to read past: “So then, my beloved, just as you have always obeyed, not as in my presence only, but now much more in my absence, work out your salvation with fear and trembling” (Phil. 2:12). Christ obeyed the Father; therefore, Paul says, keep obeying the ministry God gave you. Peter says the same: “be subject to your elders … Therefore humble yourselves under the mighty hand of God, that He may exalt you at the proper time” (1 Pet. 5:5–6). Glory comes on the heels of submission. Power comes on the heels of submission. There is no other order in the kingdom.

VII

Every gift has limits

Paul, the greatest apostle the church has known outside the Twelve, refused to step past his own boundary: “we will not boast beyond our measure, but within the measure of the sphere which God apportioned to us as a measure, to reach even as far as you” (2 Cor. 10:13). Paul uses the word measure three times in that one verse. Even an apostle has a measure, and his authority runs only as far as the sphere God assigned him. What made Corinth Paul’s sphere? Labor, love, founding, fatherly care. It was never “I am an apostle, so everything is mine.”

If Paul had limits, every gift has limits. Here is where the lines run.

  • Fatherhoodis bounded by family. Every father in a congregation is a father, but not to another man’s children.
  • Pastoringis bounded by the congregation. A pastor has a household of saints who have said, “This is where God planted me.” It is as wrong to start pastoring another pastor’s people as it is to start fathering another father’s children.
  • Discipleshipis bounded by invitation. Any believer may confront clear, demonstrable sin (Matt. 18:15). But coaching, formation, the kind of help that makes a man a better father or a better steward, requires that he ask for it. No minister among us has the right to disciple someone who has not.
  • Apostles and prophetsare mobile. They serve across congregations, bringing pattern, vision, and correction, and binding many local churches into one body. Even so, their authority is received, not imposed; Paul could plead with Corinth to open its heart to him (2 Cor. 6:11–13). He could not force it.
  • Evangelistsreach outward, to those not yet in the church. They do not presume to correct congregations, other ministries, or the church’s doctrine unless the overseeing ministries have sent them to do it.
  • Pastors and teachersare local unless sent. The Greek word for “sent” is apostellō. A pastor serving beyond his own flock is in God’s will only when he goes as an extension of the ministry that sent him.

Where each gift moves

APOSTLES & PROPHETS mobile: one pattern across many congregations CONGREGATIONCONGREGATIONCONGREGATION PTpastor · teacherPTpastor · teacherPTpastor · teacher sent EVANGELIST toward those outside
Mobile: apostle, prophet, evangelist Local unless sent: pastor, teacher
Figure 11Mobility is not rank. The pastor who never leaves his congregation is no lesser man than the apostle who travels; each is faithful to the measure of the sphere God gave him.

This raises a practical question every congregation should be able to answer: when a man speaks into our church, is he speaking from his own gift, or as an extension of someone else’s? Our teaching recognizes three ways a man may serve beyond his own place. He may carry a gift and calling himself, confirmed by the church. He may extend the ministry of another, serving under it and drawing on it. Or he may be sent for a season and a task. All three are legitimate. What is not legitimate is blurring them.

So we declare to the congregations a minister serves what his calling and scope are, and we teach our ministers to give honor where it is due. A man who passes on wisdom he received from another must not present it as his own. There is a difference between a fountain and a faucet, and children cannot always tell them apart. The faucet that pretends to be the spring has begun to steal, and before long it will try to rearrange the order of the house around itself. Diotrephes, “who loves to be first among them” (3 John 9), shows where that road ends.

VIII

Who guards the guardians?

Every form of church government finally rests on something it cannot prove from inside itself. A bishop is legitimate because other bishops say so; a pastor because a vote said so. We do not escape that problem, and we will not pretend to. But Scripture gives us safeguards, and we have tried to build ours on its pattern.

When Paul’s gospel was questioned, he did not ask his own converts to vouch for him. He laid it before James, Cephas, and John, men he had not raised and who owed him nothing, “for fear that I might be running, or had run, in vain” (Gal. 2:2). When the churches divided over circumcision, “the apostles and the elders came together to look into this matter” (Acts 15:6), and their decision went out over their shared names, not one man’s.

Safeguards at every stage

  1. InstallingNo one enters senior eldership, as apostle, prophet, evangelist, pastor, or teacher, without the unanimous consent of the presiding elders. One brother’s conscience can stop it.
  2. OverseeingA council of elders oversees the churches. Its members are the elders each ministry team names as the men it actually receives accountability from.
  3. CorrectingAny member may go to the brother, speak by the Spirit before the church, or take a concern to oversight. An elder who receives a concern must advocate for it as his own, and leaders respond within days.
  4. RemovingCharges need two or three witnesses. The man in question does not vote on his own case. Removal does not require unanimity; installing does.
  5. LeavingNo one is disciplined for leaving a congregation. The church’s final word is spoken by where its people choose to gather.
Figure 12It is harder to install an elder than to remove one. No one man’s loyalty can keep an unfit leader in place.

Confirming

Paul gave Timothy a one-line rule for this: “Do not lay hands upon anyone too hastily and thereby share responsibility for the sins of others” (1 Tim. 5:22). The hand that confers authority also shares responsibility for how it is used. That is why we make installing slow and hard.

Among us, no one is installed into senior eldership without the unanimous consent of the presiding elders. And the circle of confirmation is drawn wide on purpose. A man is not confirmed only by those he has served under, nor by his own spiritual sons, but by the whole presiding eldership, including senior elders who owe nothing to his labors or his ministry. Today our congregations are overseen by a council made up of the elders whom each ministry team names as the men it actually receives accountability from. That naming is not an election. It does not create authority; it testifies to authority already at work. Apart from that council, no one may be installed in eldership.

Removing

The same plural body that confirms a man, apostle included, can remove him, and it is meant to be easier to remove a man than to install him. When concerns are brought against an elder, they must come “on the basis of two or three witnesses” (1 Tim. 5:19). The elders weigh them without the vote of the man in question, and only after prayer, deliberation, and full opportunity for him to answer for himself. We have walked this road. In the case I have in mind, the decision did not need to be unanimous, but it was. The church was then told plainly, and with grace, what had been decided and why.

When you see something wrong

What if a member sees something genuinely amiss, in another congregation or in his own leadership? Concern is not rebellion, and we do not treat it that way. But Scripture is clear that there are honorable and dishonorable ways to carry a burden. Remember Uzzah. The ark really was wobbling, and he really did see it. God struck him anyway (2 Sam. 6:6–7), because the question was never the accuracy of his diagnosis. It was whether God had placed him to touch it. Whispering is the dishonorable way: “a slanderer separates intimate friends” (Prov. 16:28). There are three honorable ones.

  1. Go to your brother. “If your brother sins, go and show him his fault in private” (Matt. 18:15), with respect for his place.
  2. Speak by the Spirit and let the body judge. “Let two or three prophets speak, and let the others pass judgment” (1 Cor. 14:29).
  3. Take it to oversight. Paul wrote 1 Corinthians because “Chloe’s people” told him there were quarrels in the church (1 Cor. 1:11). Had Chloe’s household gossiped instead, we might not have the letter.

Our policy puts weight behind the third lane. An elder who receives a concern about another leader must advocate for it as though it were his own, whatever his personal view, and help the brother bring it before the overseeing elders. If he will not, the brother may go to another elder who will. If the elders still disagree, the concern can go before the whole body of commissioned ministers. And a concern about leadership must be acknowledged within seven days and answered substantively within fourteen.

Free to walk away

Authority that has no sword must be willing to be walked away from. Our policy is explicit: no one is disciplined for leaving a congregation, nor for suspected motives or inward attitudes, and discipline may never be used to make up for a ministry’s lack of wisdom, love, or anointing. Removal from fellowship is reserved for open, persistent sin, such as immorality, slander, divisiveness, or false teaching, and it comes with a written explanation, a path of restoration, and the right of appeal to senior leaders who had no part in the decision. Even then it marks the loss of covenant fellowship, not the end of courtesy, honest dealing, or hope. Paul’s instruction holds: “do not regard him as an enemy, but admonish him as a brother” (2 Thess. 3:15).

My father taught that a believer who has entered covenant with a church should weigh leaving it with the same sober fear he would bring to any covenant, and I still believe that. But that is counsel to a man’s conscience before God. It is not a rule the church enforces against him.

Two practical questions always follow. First, families. When a relative is under discipline, natural bonds remain. Children still honor parents, and parents still love their children. What changes is that the relationship is marked by sobriety rather than the pretense that nothing has happened, with the hope of repentance always in view, and each family finds its way with pastoral counsel rather than a rulebook. Second, livelihood. The church issues no directives about anyone’s job or home. Those decisions belong to the owners and employers involved, not to the eldership.

We have not always lived up to this. Some were removed from fellowship who should not have been, and some removals were carried out with an abruptness that wounded more than it healed. We have said so to our own ministers in writing, rewritten our policy, and committed to seek out those we wronged. Discipline without love becomes a club, and love without discipline becomes neglect. Only discipline governed by the love of Christ leads to life.

IX

The hardest questions

Anyone who teaches this will hear objections, and most of them deserve a straight answer. Here are the ones I hear most often.

“Didn’t apostles end with the Twelve?”

The Twelve were unique, and we say so without hedging. They walked with Jesus, witnessed His resurrection, and their names are on the twelve foundation stones of the New Jerusalem (Rev. 21:14). No one replaces them, and no one adds to “the faith which was once for all handed down to the saints” (Jude 3). Any apostolic ministry since then must be utterly accountable to what they gave. When God restores a neglected truth to His church, He is returning to what the Twelve already delivered, not supplementing it. So our teaching distinguishes three kinds of apostle, shown below: the Twelve, whose foundation is closed; apostles of the Lord, who restore what the Twelve gave; and apostles of the church, sent to found and order congregations.

But the New Testament plainly calls others apostles: Barnabas (Acts 14:14), Silvanus and Timothy (1 Thess. 1:1; 2:6), and the “apostles of the churches” who carried gifts between congregations (2 Cor. 8:23). And Ephesians 4 sets the duration of all five gifts with one word: until. They were given “until we all attain to the unity of the faith … to a mature man.” Has the church reached that? If not, the gifts have not expired. Those who say only Scripture-writers could be apostles have to explain why most of the apostles wrote nothing, and why Mark and Luke, who wrote a great deal, were never called apostles.

Three kinds of apostle

The TwelveRev 21:14OF THE LORDOF THE CHURCHAPOSTLES OF THE LAMBEyewitnesses chosen by Jesus;the foundation of the church.Closed: no one replaces them.APOSTLES OF THE LORDRestore truths the church lost,adding nothing to what theTwelve delivered (Gal 2:2).APOSTLES OF THE CHURCHSent by the church to foundand order congregations(Acts 14:14; 2 Cor 8:23).All bounded by “the faith … once for allhanded down” (Jude 3)
Figure 13The uniqueness of the Twelve is real, and it is guarded. What continues is sending, not new Scripture.

“Isn’t this just the Shepherding movement again?”

The Shepherding movement of the 1970s taught, as a principle, that every believer must be personally submitted to a shepherd, and authority often became a matter of rank, like a sergeant over a private. One of its own founders later publicly apologized for its excesses. We have no interest in defending it. My father lived through that era, and he refused to come under the most celebrated gift of the day while minister after minister around him did, because the attraction was a personality rather than the anointing.

The difference is not a matter of degree. That movement aimed mostly at personal stability and protection; Ephesians 4 aims at a body that displays “the manifold wisdom of God … to the rulers and the authorities in the heavenly places” (Eph. 3:10). It assigned authority on principle; Scripture grounds it in fatherhood, which has to be earned by trust and cannot be claimed. And it had few checks; in the pattern I have described, the most senior gift is the most accountable man in the room.

Have we made mistakes? Yes, and we have corrected them openly, including seasons when our own pastors watched over people too closely and had to learn to give them room to answer to God themselves. But in our experience the problems have come when we drifted from this pattern, not when we followed it.

There is something else critics rarely see. Real apostolic authority gives more away than any other arrangement in the church. Suppose a craftsman held patents on a method that had made him the most sought-after leatherworker in Texas. Would he open his files to every man who walked through his door? Of course not. Yet that is exactly what God asks of anyone He entrusts with an apostolic gift: open every drawer, hand over every pattern, and keep replacing yourself, knowing some will carry your blueprints across the street and build a rival house with them. It also respects a man’s freedom in a way the Shepherding movement did not: among us, discipleship is by invitation, and no minister has the right to disciple someone who has not asked. Paul felt that pain: “Our heart is opened wide.… open wide to us also” (2 Cor. 6:11, 13). If I wanted to serve myself, I would choose the senior pastor model in a heartbeat.

That is why Paul could write, “we might have asserted our authority. But we proved to be gentle among you, as a nursing mother tenderly cares for her own children” (1 Thess. 2:6–7). And Peter: “nor yet as lording it over those allotted to your charge, but proving to be examples to the flock” (1 Pet. 5:3).

“Wouldn’t a vote be safer?”

Israel took a vote once. Ten of the twelve spies brought back a bad report, the congregation sided with the majority, and the people said to one another, “Let us appoint a leader and return to Egypt” (Num. 14:4). The only leader the wilderness congregation ever tried to elect was a leader back to slavery. A majority can be sincere and still be wrong, and a church that settles its direction by headcount has handed its future to whoever is most numerous at the moment.

The congregation is not voiceless in the biblical pattern. Its consent is real, it tests those who claim to be apostles, and it can withdraw its trust. What it does not do is manufacture spiritual fathers by ballot.

“Aren’t these just roles anyone can step into as the Spirit leads?”

Every believer will function situationally in many gifts. We all comfort, we all share the gospel, we all speak a word in season. But the New Testament also names abiding callings. Paul calls himself “Paul … called as an apostle” (Rom. 1:1). Luke reports that “there were at Antioch … prophets and teachers” (Acts 13:1). Ephesians says Christ gave some as apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors and teachers: people, not rotating activities. “The gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable” (Rom. 11:29).

Paul answers the question himself, in the very passage where he speaks of each one’s measure: “For just as we have many members in one body and all the members do not have the same function, so we, who are many, are one body in Christ, and individually members one of another. Since we have gifts that differ according to the grace given to us, each of us is to exercise them accordingly” (Rom. 12:4–6). Not the same function. The eye does not take a turn as the hand, and the foot does not rotate into the ear. Each member is placed, and stays in its place, because that is how a body works. Paul presses it home to Corinth with a string of questions that expect the answer no: “All are not apostles, are they? All are not prophets, are they? All are not teachers, are they?” (1 Cor. 12:29). A church in which every member steps into every gift as the mood of the moment seems to lead is no body at all, only a crowd taking turns at the microphone.

And here the doctrine of the measure answers the objection directly. To say that any member may reach for any gift at will is to say that each of us has the Spirit without measure. That belongs to Jesus alone. Everyone else holds a portion, and a portion has a shape and a place.

We learned this the hard way. In our fellowship’s early years my father became convinced the church needed a plural eldership of equals. With no one to counsel him, he took a step of faith and signed the church over, making himself one voice among several, most of them converts of less than three years. It was an enormous risk. But the brothers kept bringing him their questions, and he watched their efforts to help one another dissolve into friction whenever his gift was absent and sort themselves out whenever it was present. So he went back to Scripture to understand what had proven true in practice. Was there an order among the gifts? There was. Everyone was equal as a son of God, bought by the same blood. The gifts were not identical, and the body could not function as if they were.

“Doesn’t Scripture say we are already complete in Christ?”

It does: “in Him you have been made complete” (Col. 2:10). But notice where the completeness is. It is in Him, and Paul has just said that in Christ “all the fullness of Deity dwells in bodily form” (2:9). The completeness belongs to the whole Christ, Head and body together, and each of us shares in it as one member of an entire body. You are part of the full measure. You are not the full measure.

John writes, “you have no need for anyone to teach you” (1 John 2:27). He means you do not need one carnal head to instruct another, because the anointing itself teaches you. He plainly does not mean the Spirit will never use teachers, or he would not be teaching while he writes it.

And Paul commands, “be filled with the Spirit” (Eph. 5:18). Filling describes how full a vessel is, not how large. A cup filled to the brim is full, and it is still a cup. Being filled with the Spirit is having your measure brimming over, not possessing all of Christ in one person. That is why Paul goes straight on to “speaking to one another” (5:19). Even the filled believer receives through the others.

“What about women?”

Every member of the body ministers, and women are no exception. Women prophesy (Acts 21:9; 1 Cor. 11:5), serve the church (Rom. 16:1), teach younger women (Titus 2:3–5), labor in the gospel (Phil. 4:3), help instruct men like Apollos in the way of God more accurately (Acts 18:26), and exercise the full range of the Spirit’s gifts. On the basis of Paul’s plain instructions (1 Tim. 2:12; 3:2), the governing offices of eldership are given to men. We hold that without apology, and without the slightest diminishment of the women among us, whose gifts the church could not live without.

“Isn’t passing leadership from father to son just a dynasty?”

It would be, if natural sonship conferred anything. It confers nothing. Elisha was not Elijah’s son by birth, and Timothy was not Paul’s, yet each was a true son in the faith (1 Tim. 1:2). Among us, calling never passes by natural lineage. Any instance where a leader’s son is also called to leadership is incidental, owing nothing at all to his family name. Every such leader must be recognized over years of fruit and confirmed unanimously by the presiding elders, and the same body that installs him can remove him.

“Then why does no one in your churches go by ‘Apostle’?”

Because the gifts are functions and responsibilities, not titles. In our churches you will never hear a man introduce himself as “Apostle So-and-so” or “Prophet So-and-so.” We call one another brother. Jesus said, “do not be called Rabbi; for One is your Teacher, and you are all brothers” (Matt. 23:8). A gift is proven by its fruit, not its title. “A man’s gift makes room for him” (Prov. 18:16); it does not have to announce itself.

Then why speak of apostolic ministry at all? For the same reason Scripture does: to understand and honor how God works. We name a gift when it needs to be explained; we do not wear it. When Paul wrote “Paul, called as an apostle,” he was stating what he had been sent to do, not telling the church how to address him.

“So are churches without the fivefold ministry not real churches?”

Wherever people walk in sincere faith in Christ, call on the Lord from a pure heart (2 Tim. 2:22), and strive to live by His word, we honor them as brothers. When we say there is no salvation outside the church, we mean outside Christ’s body, not outside our organization. What congregations without this order lack is not salvation. It is the ordered supply of grace that brings a body to maturity and to the unity Jesus prayed for. We would rather show that than argue it.

X

Known by its fruit

Read Ephesians 4:14 again: “As a result, we are no longer to be children, tossed here and there by waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine, by the trickery of men, by craftiness in deceitful scheming.” That is a result clause, and result clauses run in both directions. If the fivefold ministry, working as Paul describes, produces a people who are no longer tossed about, then a people tossed about by every new teacher, podcast, and political mood is evidence that the fivefold ministry is not working among them, however impressive the titles on the church sign.

This is just the fruit test applied to government. “You will know them by their fruits” (Matt. 7:16). Paul applied it to himself: “If to others I am not an apostle, at least I am to you; for you are the seal of my apostleship in the Lord” (1 Cor. 9:2).

Picture shopping for an architect. You drive past a dozen houses he has built, and they are sound, beautiful, and still standing after thirty winters. Then you meet another man standing in front of a shack of rusted tin and cardboard, shouting through a megaphone that he is the finest architect in the state. You would laugh him out of town. The loudest architect is not the best architect. The best building shows you the best architect.

The architect test

THE LOUDEST ARCHITECT“the finest in the state”THE BEST BUILDINGstill standing after thirty winters“Each man’s work will become evident; for the day will show it.” 1 Cor 3:13
Figure 14A builder is proven by what stands because of him.
The question of submitting to apostolic ministry doesn’t even begin until you find a church that is visibly growing into what the Bible promised.

No church on earth yet looks exactly like the one Paul describes. The New Testament churches did not either; Corinth had its factions and Galatia its legalists, and Paul still wrote to both as the church of God. What matters is the direction a church is moving. Look for a people who are moving toward the pattern rather than away from it: a restoration of unity that ordinary church life cannot explain, gifts flourishing instead of competing, families holding together across generations, leaders who can be corrected and stay brothers. When you find a body bearing that kind of fruit, and bearing more of it year by year, then ask: could this have happened without the gifts Christ gave?

This is a long test, and it should be. A single failure does not refute a pattern, any more than a single success proves it. Leaders in every kind of church sin; members in every kind of church get hurt; we have had our share of both. The question is what a pattern produces across decades and generations: whether churches built on it hold together, whether their children carry the faith, whether their leaders can be corrected and still remain brothers. Gamaliel gave the council the right measure: “if this plan or action is of men, it will be overthrown; but if it is of God, you will not be able to overthrow them” (Acts 5:38–39). We are content to be judged that way.

Our fellowship has not arrived. We have corrected course on matters of baptism, communion, and discipleship, and we will correct course again. When visitors spend time among our congregations, the thing they mention most is the way the people hold together. Our elders work together without protracted quarrels, and we have never split over a decision. Students of religious movements have told us they had never before seen a new work pass intact to its second generation. One of them said to my father, “The key is that you did it while you were still alive.” Whatever unity God has given us has come, as far as I can tell, from men who know the difference between a call to pastor, a call to prophesy, a call to teach, and a call to lay foundations, and who would rather belong to one another than build platforms of their own. Unity in the truth has been the fruit, and the order of gifts is what it grows from. But unity is not the final harvest; people can be united in error. The final harvest is God’s eternal purpose, His manifold wisdom made known through the church (Eph. 3:10–11).

—

Enough together

Come back to where we started. “But to each one of us grace was given according to the measure of Christ’s gift.”

If you have felt your own insufficiency, if you have prayed and studied and fasted and still sensed that something was missing, you have not failed. You have discovered how you were made. Your measure tells you where you belong and whom you need.

A Christian who is not truly joined to a body, however sincere, is trying to live on his own first picking, one measure of the Spirit, when God never gave anyone enough to grow up alone. A congregation that stands apart, with a pastor but no apostolic, prophetic, or evangelistic ministry joined to it, is trying to grip with one finger. Neither was God’s idea. When Christ ascended, He gave Himself again, divided into gifts placed in real men, so that what He deposited in them could reach you, and what He deposited in you could reach others. That happens only when you are actually joined: in covenant with a local body, under ministries you know and trust, and pouring your own portion back into it.

“Speaking the truth in love, we are to grow up in all aspects into Him who is the head, even Christ, from whom the whole body, being fitted and held together by what every joint supplies, according to the proper working of each individual part, causes the growth of the body for the building up of itself in love.”

Ephesians 4:15–16

Nobody climbs to the stature of Christ by himself. The body grows up together, joint by joint, or it does not grow up. And when it does, the glory goes where Paul said it would: “to Him be the glory in the church and in Christ Jesus to all generations forever and ever. Amen” (Eph. 3:21).

For further study

Blair Adams, Forming Christ’s Body, Books One, Two, and Three. My own teaching on this subject rests on my father’s searching of the Scriptures; any shortcomings in this summary are mine.

A. Z. Adams, The Fivefold Ministry: God’s Right Hand of Power.

A note on Scripture

Scripture quotations are from the New American Standard Bible (1995). Greek terms are given in simple transliteration.

A. Z. Adams